
It has been a week since the Athens City-County Health Department first reported Shiga toxin-producing E. coli (STEC) infections in Athens County, Ohio. I have written about it on November 11, November 13 and November 16 here, and yesterday at Food Poison Journal. The count has gone from four to sixteen. The department’s most recent written statement, a release dated November 16, contains three sentences of fact and a list of handwashing advice.
NBC4 in Columbus reports that the department plans another update on the morning of Wednesday, November 18. Before it arrives, here is the ledger as it stands.
What we know
- Sixteen laboratory-confirmed STEC cases. The count “reached sixteen” as of the afternoon of November 16, according to the release. It was four on November 11 and eleven on November 13.
- Every one is an Ohio University student on the Athens campus. Jack Pepper, the department’s administrator, told WOWK that food histories are how investigators learned the cluster was confined to the university and, within it, to students.
- The illness onset dates line up. The release says early investigation has confirmed consistent symptom onset dates among all sixteen. WOUB put it plainly: all sixteen developed symptoms around the same time. That is the pattern of a point source, a single food, meal or event, and not of an exposure that is still going on.
- The later cases are later lab results, not later illnesses. Pepper told WOWK the newest cases likely share the same source as the first ones and that their test results had only just been reported.
- The department thinks the worst has passed. WSAZ reported that the department believes the risk is “rapidly declining” and that there is no ongoing contamination.
- Interviews are under way. Investigators are plotting where each student went and what each ate to see whether the exposures trace to one source, WOUB reported.
- The university is cleaning and communicating. Ohio University told Spectrum News 1 that dining staff disinfect dining areas with hospital-grade products after every meal, and it is posting updates through its campus alert system. Its food safety staff walked through campus kitchens last week, The Post reported.
- Sixteen is a floor. A confirmed case is someone who sought care, gave a stool sample and tested positive. Food Safety News notes CDC’s estimate that many more infections go undetected for each one confirmed.
What we don’t know
- The source. No food, dining hall, restaurant, catered event, animal contact or water exposure has been named, and none has been ruled out in public.
- The dates. The department says the onset dates are consistent but has not said what they are. With onset dates in hand and a typical incubation of three to four days, investigators can bracket the exposure to a few days. Students and parents have not been told which days.
- The bug. STEC is a category. Nobody has said whether this is O157:H7 or a non-O157 strain, which Shiga toxin it carries, or whether whole genome sequencing has been done. Sequencing would show whether the sixteen share one strain and whether that strain matches illnesses anywhere else, which would point to a commercially distributed food.
- How sick the students are. No number has been given for hospitalizations or for hemolytic uremic syndrome (HUS), the kidney complication that CDC says typically appears about a week after symptoms begin. Without onset dates, families cannot tell whether that window has closed.
- Whether it is over. WSAZ has the department calling the risk rapidly declining. WOUB reported that because the source is unidentified, it is unknown whether there is an ongoing risk. Both cannot be the public message.
- Who else is sick. There has been no count of probable or suspect cases, no word on pending tests, and no statement on whether any dining worker, staff member or town resident is ill.
- Where the sixteen ate and lived. On campus or off, which residence halls, which dining halls, which meal plans. Meal plan card records can show who ate where and when. No one has said whether they have been pulled.
- What has been tested besides people. No word on food samples, environmental swabs, retained product or testing of food workers.
- Who is helping. The Ohio Department of Health, the Ohio Department of Agriculture, CDC and FDA have not been mentioned in any release.
- The plan for Thanksgiving. The holiday is November 26. Students will scatter across Ohio and beyond within days, and no notice to clinicians or home health departments has been described.
Why the gaps matter
When officials say nothing about the source, students fill in the blank themselves. One student told Spectrum News 1 she is avoiding lettuce. Another said it is hard to know what to avoid when nobody knows the source. Some students on meal plans are wary of the dining halls. None of them has any basis for those choices, and they should not have to guess.
The department’s own statement is the best news in this outbreak. If the onset dates cluster tightly, the exposure was most likely brief and is most likely over. That is a reason to say more, not less.
What the next update should include
- The epidemic curve. Sixteen onset dates on a chart, with the estimated exposure window marked.
- The serotype and the sequencing status. What the strain is, and whether it matches anything outside Athens County.
- Hospitalizations and HUS. A number, even if the number is zero.
- The working hypotheses. What has been ruled out is as useful to students as what has been ruled in.
- A commitment to a written final report.
If you are a student or a parent
Severe cramps and diarrhea, especially bloody diarrhea, mean a visit to a provider and a request for a stool test. If you are heading home, tell the provider you were in Athens. Decreased urination, unusual fatigue and loss of color in the cheeks are reasons to go to an emergency room. Wash your hands, and do not prepare food for others while you are sick. The health department’s number is 740-592-4431.
I have been doing E. coli cases since the Jack in the Box outbreak in 1993. The outbreaks that get solved are the ones where the interviews, the records and the lab work are done fast and the public is told what is known, including what is not.